Wednesday, September 08, 2010

Book Review - The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway

SynopsisThe Sun Also Rises was Ernest Hemingway's first big novel, and immediately established Hemingway as one of the great prose stylists, and one of the preeminent writers of his time. It is also the book that encapsulates the angst of the post-World War I generation, known as the Lost Generation. This poignantly beautiful story of a group of American and English expatriates in Paris on an excursion to Pamplona represents a dramatic step forward for Hemingway's evolving style. Featuring Left Bank Paris in the 1920s and brutally realistic descriptions of bullfighting in Spain, the story is about the flamboyant Lady Brett Ashley and the hapless Jake Barnes. In an age of moral bankruptcy, spiritual dissolution, unrealized love, and vanishing illusions, this is the Lost Generation.
First Line:  "Robert Cohn was once middleweight boxing champion of Princeton."
Random Quote:  "It was hot, but the town had a cool, fresh, early-morning smell and it was pleasant sitting in the cafe.  A breeze started to blow, and you could feel that the air came from the sea.  There were pigeons out in the square and the houses were a yellow, sun-baked color, and I did not want to leave the cafe."
Review:  This has always been one of my favorite books.  I first read it when I was in high school and I started being interested in Paris in the twenties.  Prior to that I had spent hours sitting on the floor in my father's kitchen looking at the pictures in The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas or maybe they were in The Alice B. Toklas Cookbook (we had both).  I liked those pictures because of the funny hats and cool cars and because Ms. Stein and Ms. Toklas had standard poodles and I also had a standard poodle.  In any event, all of this eventually sparked an interest in The Lost Generation and I read all kinds of things that weren't assigned by my various (dreadful) honors English teachers - lots of novels, some poetry, a fair amount of biography and non-fiction.

PAMPLONA, SPAIN - JULY 07: Fighting bulls and ...Running with the bulls - Pamplona - Image by Getty Images via @daylife
During earlier reads of this book I liked most the romance of it - the running of the bulls, the bistros and cafes, and Jake and Brett's doomed romance.  I remember liking the idea of Brett, too, sort of adventurous and tragic in her own way.  The writing was also excellent - so simple and so evocative.
At this point in my life I still love this book, although this time I was most attracted to Hemingway's descriptions of journeying through the countryside - sitting on top of the bus, walking in Spain, fishing, the sights and sounds of San Fermin.  I liked Brett a lot less and found their romantic problems somewhat less compelling (there are so many more options for expressing sexuality than either Jake or Brett allowed for).  It's interesting how books change as you do.

FTC Disclosure:  Purchased from Half-Price Books

Rating:  Orange

Reading Challenges:  Decades 2010 (1920's)
Enhanced by Zemanta

7 comments:

  1. I love Hemingway! I haven't read this one yet, though -- I read quite a bit of Hemingway (my favorites being The Old Man and the Sea and A Moveable Feast) to prepare for heading to Key West to cheer my Dad on in the annual Hemingway Look Alike competition which is absolutely hilarious and fun (not to mention, it's such a longstanding and famous event, the winners get interviewed on the spot by USA Today, Good Morning America, etc.) -- it is a blast! THe Hemingway Home in Key West is incredible, too -- he loved six-toed cats, and they have about 50 of them running around the house and grounds! Some of my older posts from this June/July have Hemingway stuff, and I happened to find a great blog called www.thehemingwayproject.com -- Allie is fantastic with her research!

    Can you tell I'm a Hemingway fan? :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for reminding me why I liked this book so much the first time I read it. Perhaps I'm due for a reread.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "It's interesting how books change as you do."

    Or, better yet, how are views of books change as we do.

    Interestingly, a recently published novelist over at "The Millions" web site recently declared that today's writers should not read books by dead authors because they and their grandchildren don't need the money and living authors do. He singled out Hemingway as an example.

    In response to this, an upstairs neighbor of mine, Hugh Lafferty, seems to embrace this idea in a manner rather typical of him. You can read his response here: http://hughlaff.blogspot.com/

    Thomas Burchfield
    http://www.redroom.com/member/thomas-burchfield

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love this book too, especially the subject matter. It's been awhile since I've read it though, and I was wondering, do you feel there is any sexism in the way Brett's presented? Hemingway's been criticized for portraying this sexually liberated woman as a constant danger to male friendships.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Always one of my top 1 or 2, and always will be.

    I agree that the countryside is more attractive, pure and beautiful than anything civilized Paris can offer. Hemingway can get more out of a couple of trout in a creel and a running joke between friends ("utilize") than anyone ever.

    ReplyDelete
  6. @E.L. - I think it's really hard to say who's sexist - Hemingway or the times or both. I debate with myself about whether or not I can hold a young man in the 1920's to the same standard I would hold someone now and yet there were men who overcame their cultural training. This book was published in 1926 at which point women in the States had only had the right to vote for 6 years. I guess I think the past is pretty much a different world.

    With regard to Brett I don't like her a lot, honestly, but I've known women like her even today. It's a smaller canvas of options to draw from, I suppose. I'm not sure Hemingway liked women all that much, but I'm also not entirely sure I care. For me the writing in the book makes it worthwhile.

    I think it's sort of like hating Huck Finn because Twain uses the n-word. I love Huck Finn, despite the n-word, and in some ways I think Twain rather successfully skewers the myth of Southern gentility and the realities of racism in that book.

    Good question!

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is one of my all time favorites, as well, along with A Farewell To Arms. Brett is hard to like, but I think Hemingway has a point about women's emerging sexual freedom. It did a lot of them much more harm than good because a line gets crossed. It's one thing to choose; it's another to sell yourself out, which is what Brett did.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks! As I'm sure you know, comments rock!