First Line: "I grew up on a farm."
Random Quote: "No way they'd have something like this back in the States. I thought back to Manzanar, the American concentration camp I'd visited in the California desert. In some ways, that was very similar to this place, a vista of old wire and empty foundations. Only we dismantled our camps, let the desert reclaim them. Except for a roadside plaque, nothing remains to tell the tale, to cop to our own guilt."
Review: This was terribly disappointing. The annoyances were numerous including, but not limited to:
- The format of the book - It's printed in newspaper type with two columns per page as if it were still a zine. It makes reading it difficult.
- The introduction - This is printed as in a regular book and starts out okay, but quickly devolves into self-congratulatory drivel. Yes, yes, you are the coolest, gothest ever. We all bow to your amazingness.
- The writing - Almost universally mediocre. These were the 40 best items?
- The illustrations - If you had a goth friend in high school who doodled cartoons in their notebook, you'll recognize these.
Out of 298 pages and 40 or so essays only one of them was worth reading - Souvenir of Hell by Brian Thomas - about visiting Auschwitz and Birkenau. Thank you, Mr. Thomas, for writing about this experience in an intelligent and honest way.
This book got two stars because of Mr. Thomas' essay - a long-winded way of saying you might as well skip this.


![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_c.png?x-id=0e2550d6-94cf-4173-a3ba-ea7a3a094062)
Too bad!
ReplyDeleteAlthough I confess that I sometimes I awfully enjoy writing a negative review. :)
Have a Merry Christmas! And a happy new year of reading and blogging!
Thanks for following Rose City Reader!